The Let's Play Archive

Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney

by DKII

Part 24: Episode 2, Trial: A Glorious Meltdown

Part 24: Episode 2, Trial: A Glorious Meltdown



This choice can be tricky, but not so tricky that the Attorney's Badge should have that many votes. In fact, there are twice as many votes here as we've had before; you lot are rather mischievous, hmm?



The game reminds us when we first get the cell phone, to check the court record for it. However if you didn't do that, and didn't hear the recorded conversation, you might not remember why it's the perfect choice here. Checking this recorded conversation is also a way to remember for the prompts last update that the statue was empty and missing its clockwork.



Music: Telling the Truth



Hmm. That's a very cute cell phone.

Ooh hoo! You have a girlie phone!



Listen!





quote:

Incorrect evidence doesn't incur a penalty here, but we do get more smug Edgeworth.



What do you say to that?

W-what? I don't rightly understand what that's supposed to mean!

I don't rightly understand either.

Ho hoh!

(Uh oh... I think I blew it.)

Mr. Wright, please refrain from flippant presentations of evidence in the future.

S-sorry, Your Honor!

I tried to submit the wiretap just to see if that would get a reaction from anyone, but no dice. We just get brought back to the same prompt to present the evidence, though, so worst case you can just present everything we have at this point!



The crowd is excited again, though we haven't really said what's on the recording yet.



Order! Order!



Holy shit we actually broke Edgeworth! Take that dickhead! We're not dumb enough to accidentally text you the records, either!



*grumble* (The good detective better remember he's up for evaluation soon...)

(I gotta say, I'm starting to feel bad for the big fella.)

Let's hear the conversation.

Music: Silence





[If you could.]



[Huh? It's not working? That's lame!]

[I had to take the clockwork out, sorry.]





There are loud annoying beep effects for the start and end of the recording. Sounds almost like old dialup internet noises.

Music: Telling the Truth

Your Honor,







Luckily, when she was first introduced, Miss May said that she had checked in after lunch on the day of the murder.





Just how did you know that weapon was a clock!?

...

W-well...!



One last attempt at an excuse coming...

I saw that clock before!



Oops! I forgot! *wink*



It would, if we hadn't seen the epilogue for the previous episode!



You bet we do!

The witness claims she had "seen it before."

quote:

If we don't object there, we get a longer scene.

Oh right... well, if she had seen it before, I guess...

(Wait a second!)

Then, the court would like--

Hold on! P-please wait, Your Honor!

Y-yes...? So you do have an objection?

Um, yes, well...

Mr. Wright!

Sorry, Your Honor, it's just...

The witness claims she had "seen it before."

But we still end up at the same place!



Well then, let's see it.





We get to use the same piece of evidence twice! Twisty, but not all that difficult to figure out here. Oh hey, the description changed at some point since we last used it! Anyway, this clock is handmade, so it couldn't have been seen in a store!



quote:

We can get this one wrong without penalty as well, but who wants to let the pressure off of Edgeworth at this point?

Here is undeniable proof!

Hah!?

Please, this is a court case, not some surrealist performance art piece!

Hmm... Perhaps the defense would like to change its mind?

From there we just get asked to present the right evidence again.



You know, in this shot, his hair does look kind of spiky. Never mind, carry on.

This clock was never in any store, ever!





Only two exist in the world.

And the one that isn't here is in police custody!





Mmpf...

Oh? Excuses not on sale today?



I think we're about to see another meltdown. Are you ready?





Well, we didn't get physically assaulted, at least. What's with those eyes now?

Music: Pressing Pursuit - Cornered



I left this one as an animation to show that the facial tic is still there. Looks like Miss May has finally dropped her act! In fact, she's rather intimidating now!

That stupid clock doesn't matter, okay!?



This fictional setting is big on executions I guess. That and people who want to kill our clients via framing them for murder. Fun fact: Japan and the United States are the only two of the world's wealthiest countries that still execute its worst criminal offenders.



The crowd is once again excited by the outburst.



W-w-whoa! Let's not get ahead of ourselves.





Miss May, uh, partially recovers.

Oh! Oh? Oh hoh ho! S-silly me! *grunt*

Did I, um, like... lose it?



(S-scary...)

Miss May, let me ask.





Hmm... oh dear.



(Okay, this is it!)





Ohh this is where the wiretap comes in! She heard about it!

The witness had never held the clock in her hand!



She "heard"...?

That is correct, Your Honor.





And I can show you the proof!

Well, this is interesting.



quote:

We could also say that Miss May had held the clock, even though it doesn't really make sense...

(This is familiar territory. I'll just use the same approach as with Larry.)

Miss May held that very clock in her hands!

Mr. Wright! When was this!?

When she used it to strike the victim! When else?

(The crowd gets excited again, followed by another triple gavel strike.)

Order! Order!

Mr. Wright! What is the meaning of this!?

April May, you killed Mia Fey, I say!

And when you struck, the force of the impact made "The Thinker" ring!

That's when you heard it!

Dude, that was last case.



Music: Silence

Tsk tsk.

You truly are a work of art, Mr. Phoenix Wright.

W-what's that supposed to mean!?

It was you who just proved that "The Thinker" was empty!

Oh... (Urk! Of course it wouldn't ring!)

What's more, the witness has a rock-solid alibi.

Miss May?

Perhaps you could explain to the poor, misguided Mr. Wright?

That you were in the hotel at the time of the murder.

(S-she can't prove it! She did it!)

It would be MY pleasure!

Music: Pressing Pursuit - Cornered - Variation

N-no way!

Yes way, Mr. Lawyer.

Tee hee? Didn't the murder take place at 9:00 at night?

Gee, that's the exact time I ordered some room service from the hotel bellboy!

Incidentally, the bellboy corroborates the witness's story.

Ergo, she was not at the crime scene! Rock solid!

(More crowd excitement, followed by a single gavel strike.)

Mr. Wright! You've just made a serious accusation against a perfectly innocent woman!

No actual penalty though, other than looking stupid.

S-sorry, Your Honor. (That... didn't go so well.)

(But, if that's the case...)

(Then how did she know "The Thinker" was a clock!?)

(...)

(Wait!)

Your Honor, I figured it out!

There is one other way Miss April May could have known it was a clock!

One way alone! And I have proof!

Well... proof, you say?

Then, the court will examine your proof, Mr. Wright.

That was a long sidetrack, but we do end up in the same place eventually.



It's the wiretap! She heard it on the same phone conversation we just used to prove the statue/clock was empty!



quote:

If we're wrong...

This evidence reveals the truth of the matter!

What does it reveal, exactly?

The mad delusions of the defense, perhaps?

(Uh oh, bad reaction. Maybe that wasn't the thing...)

I'm afraid it has revealed a certain over-eagerness...

Let me ask again:

And we're brought back up to the top to try again! Still no penalty; this episode is taking it easy on us!





I found this in Miss May's room.



The crowd wonders what exactly Phoenix was doing in Miss May's room...





Miss April May?



Oooh. Oooooh!





Your Honor, this is irrelevant!



The judge is on our side this time without us even having to speak up first!

It troubles me that our witness was in possession of a wiretap.



Absolutely!

Even if that was the case, which it's not, you still have to prove one thing!



Uh, yeah? In the exact same recorded conversation we just played for you?





I love those random zoomed-in animations. Like they were transported to a higher dimension to do battle.





Here's my proof.



I guess we'll just throw the cell phone at him again. I'm a little concerned that we seem to be wrapping up with Miss May and we still have two unused pieces of evidence, though.



quote:

Of course, we could be wrong...

This!

I think...

That's not going to prove anything, Mr. Wright.

I think...

W-wait! That was just a warm up!

Hmm! Okay, once again. And I expect real proof this time!

We can once again retry without penalty here, as many times as we want!



Yes, we've seen that.



Music: Silence



[Mia! What's up? You haven't called in a while.]

[Well, actually there's something I want you to hold on to for me.]

[Again? What's it this time?]

[It's... a clock.]

[It's made to look like that statue, "The Thinker." And it tells you the time!]



You used a wiretap to listen to this conversation!





Am I wrong!?







Your Honor, this is ridiculous!





The defense demands an answer.





...

Miss May!



You... you LAWYER!



We get a series of reaction shots, followed by a silent crowd for once. Phoenix why are you sweating there?



Oh, so I'm the bad girl, is that it? Is that it!?







Well we know she didn't actually do it herself, so I guess we'll ask about the wiretap?

Music: Objection!



...



Answer the question!

Do I have to?





Miss May.

You were tapping the victim's phone!







Looks like the crowd is on our side.





Well, Miss May? Do you have an explanation for the court?



That's...not really what we asked. I was trying to dig at why she put the wiretap on in the first place! Something about what Mia was investigating set this whole thing off!

(Hah! I'd like to see her pull THAT off!)

Mr. Lawyer, I saw that evil, evil grin!



(Damn... she's good!)



quote:

Since the judge kind of did it anyway, let's accuse her of murder again!

Music: Trial

Miss May!

What is it you little shrimp! Talk to me in that tone of voice will you!?

You killed her, didn't you!

(The accusation gets the crowd going again, necessitating a triple gavel strike!)

Order! There will be order!

What? How can you possibly say that!? Are you mad?

A-all I did was a little wiretapping...

Oops!

So you admit you tapped her phone!

Heh... heh... hrrah!

B-but wait!

I didn't do ANYTHING bad like murder! I'm a good girl!

Really?

Can you prove it!?

(No way can she prove it!)

You think you're so smart, Mr. Lawyer...

But I can prove it! And I will!

Music: Silence





Hmph!

Okay? So, the killing happened around 9:00 at night?



It suddenly occurs to me to wonder exactly what kind of "service" she was getting, particularly with how the bellboy reacted to our visit....

R-room service!?

Ice coffee, I believe it was?





I-ice coffee...!?





You know, the more I think about it, we haven't really gotten anywhere here. The bloody note is still in play, and Miss May's credibility may be shot but all we've proven so far is that she had a connection to the victim. We haven't really taken out her testimony about identifying Maya as the killer.



Apparently Phoenix thinks it's time to panic as well.



The crowd's all, "Hey, the smug asshole makes a pretty good point!" And we're back to square one.







That the witness appears to have been tapping the victim's telephone.



However! That is a separate crime, with no bearing on the current case whatsoever!



(No! They're goint to let her just walk away!)



Well, does the defense have anything to say?



Music: Suspense



I'm not sure what else we can ask Miss May, but I'm also not sure what questioning the bellboy is going to accomplish. Still I guess we're better off with the unknown, maybe we'll learn something new!



There's something suspicious here, and I'm going to get to the bottom of it!







Can he do that? Why even have a defense attorney in a criminal trial?

W-why? What's your reason?



...!

However...



I'm not going to like this, am I?

Condition...?



then you will recognize that Miss April May was not the killer, thus she is innocent!



This seems like a trap, particularly since we know Miss May isn't the killer. But what other option do we really have?

That is my condition.

(What...!?)



(Otherwise Maya will be declared "guilty" on the spot!)



Might as well see this thing through, I guess.



That's the spirit.



Hmph.



Yup, trap. Here we go.

(Uh oh!)

Uh... um, wait...

quote:

Giving up isn't really an option, as you might have guessed:

(Grr! I can't accept those conditions!)

Very well. The defense will refrain from calling the bellboy as a witness.

I see. You may continue your cross-examination, Mr. Wright.

I haven't shown the dialogue you get by declining to call the bellboy the first time we're asked. That's because, from here, the dialogue is exactly the same both times we back off. Except it doesn't make sense the first time, because it references the "deal" we just got offered.

Right. On with the cross-examination.

What exactly do you have left to examine, Mr. Wright?

Miss April May has admitted to the wiretap, yes.

But that bears no relevance to the case at hand: murder!

There's no way you can prove any connection!

(Uh oh! Think! This can't be the end... but I'm out of evidence!)

Then I believe the cross-examination is over.

Mr. Edgeworth, does the prosecution have any other witnesses to call?

None, Your Honor. She's the last.

Music: Silence

(What!? B-but that means...)

(Maya's guilty...!?)

W-wait! Your Honor!

Yes, Mr. Wright?

The defense would like to call the bellboy after all!

...

Tsk tsk tsk...

As I thought!

...?

May I remind you, dear Mr. Wright. Should you question the bellboy...

and Miss April May's alibi prove to be solid...

then, by default, your client Ms. Maya Fey will be pronounced "guilty"!

Are you prepared to accept my condition?

(Edgeworth...)

(He's got me backed into a corner...)

(But I don't see any other way to take this!)

I accept!



Music: Silence

Very well!



I did not really expect to be seeing this guy again.